{ "id": 395233, "title": "More Fragment Dataset Allowed?", "url": "/competitions/vesuvius-challenge-ink-detection/discussion/395233", "author_name": "", "post_date": "2023-03-16T12:59:53.806922600Z", "votes": 4, "comment_count": 1, "views": 0, "content": "

In the webpage https://scrollprize.org/data we have thousands of fragments listed to download, but it is said that

\n
\n

If you are just entering the Kaggle competition and not working on the grand prize, you do not need to download any data from this page; all the relevant fragment data is available via Kaggle.

\n
\n

I want to confirm, are we not allowed to use this data in our solution?

\n

@jpposma

", "messages": [ { "id": "2184547", "postDate": "03/16/2023 12:59:53", "content": "

In the webpage https://scrollprize.org/data we have thousands of fragments listed to download, but it is said that

\n
\n

If you are just entering the Kaggle competition and not working on the grand prize, you do not need to download any data from this page; all the relevant fragment data is available via Kaggle.

\n
\n

I want to confirm, are we not allowed to use this data in our solution?

\n

@jpposma

", "rawMarkdown": "In the webpage https://scrollprize.org/data we have thousands of fragments listed to download, but it is said that\n\n>If you are just entering the Kaggle competition and not working on the grand prize, you do not need to download any data from this page; all the relevant fragment data is available via Kaggle.\n\nI want to confirm, are we not allowed to use this data in our solution?\n\n@jpposma", "votes": null }, { "id": "2184750", "postDate": "03/16/2023 15:44:36", "content": "

You are allowed to use any data from https://scrollprize.org/data in your training, but let me clarify the difference between that data and the Kaggle data.

\n

The fragment data that you can download from https://scrollprize.org/data are from the same fragments as the data hosted on Kaggle. The difference is that the 3D X-ray scans on Kaggle have been processed to be “surface volumes”, which means that the data on Kaggle is much smaller, and contains information just around the surface of the fragments, which is the only information relevant for training models. The tutorials go into more detail in how we went from the raw data to these surface volumes that we host on Kaggle.

\n

The data on https://scrollprize.org/data are the raw original scans, and contain way more information than you should need. But we might be wrong, and you might find useful information in there, so feel free to use it!

", "rawMarkdown": "You are allowed to use any data from https://scrollprize.org/data in your training, but let me clarify the difference between that data and the Kaggle data.\n\nThe fragment data that you can download from https://scrollprize.org/data are from the same fragments as the data hosted on Kaggle. The difference is that the 3D X-ray scans on Kaggle have been processed to be “surface volumes”, which means that the data on Kaggle is much smaller, and contains information just around the surface of the fragments, which is the only information relevant for training models. The [tutorials](https://scrollprize.org/tutorial1) go into more detail in how we went from the raw data to these surface volumes that we host on Kaggle.\n\nThe data on https://scrollprize.org/data are the raw original scans, and contain way more information than you should need. But we might be wrong, and you might find useful information in there, so feel free to use it!", "votes": null } ], "comments": [ { "id": 2184750, "author_name": "jpposma", "author_url": "", "post_date": "03/16/2023 15:44:36", "content": "

You are allowed to use any data from https://scrollprize.org/data in your training, but let me clarify the difference between that data and the Kaggle data.

\n

The fragment data that you can download from https://scrollprize.org/data are from the same fragments as the data hosted on Kaggle. The difference is that the 3D X-ray scans on Kaggle have been processed to be “surface volumes”, which means that the data on Kaggle is much smaller, and contains information just around the surface of the fragments, which is the only information relevant for training models. The tutorials go into more detail in how we went from the raw data to these surface volumes that we host on Kaggle.

\n

The data on https://scrollprize.org/data are the raw original scans, and contain way more information than you should need. But we might be wrong, and you might find useful information in there, so feel free to use it!

", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ], "raw_markdown_by_id": { "2184547": "In the webpage https://scrollprize.org/data we have thousands of fragments listed to download, but it is said that\n\n>If you are just entering the Kaggle competition and not working on the grand prize, you do not need to download any data from this page; all the relevant fragment data is available via Kaggle.\n\nI want to confirm, are we not allowed to use this data in our solution?\n\n@jpposma", "2184750": "You are allowed to use any data from https://scrollprize.org/data in your training, but let me clarify the difference between that data and the Kaggle data.\n\nThe fragment data that you can download from https://scrollprize.org/data are from the same fragments as the data hosted on Kaggle. The difference is that the 3D X-ray scans on Kaggle have been processed to be “surface volumes”, which means that the data on Kaggle is much smaller, and contains information just around the surface of the fragments, which is the only information relevant for training models. The [tutorials](https://scrollprize.org/tutorial1) go into more detail in how we went from the raw data to these surface volumes that we host on Kaggle.\n\nThe data on https://scrollprize.org/data are the raw original scans, and contain way more information than you should need. But we might be wrong, and you might find useful information in there, so feel free to use it!" }, "source": "meta" }