Hi to all!
\nToday I noticed that my public notebooks have shifted from the top of the \"Hotness\" list to the end. Out of curiosity, someone knows what's going on?
\nI noticed that at first, after the publication of the notebook, it goes down for a while at the end of the list, but then rises to the top so that everyone can see it. But I never noticed (did not pay attention) that the long-published notebook went down to the bottom of the list.
Hi to all!
\nToday I noticed that my public notebooks have shifted from the top of the \"Hotness\" list to the end. Out of curiosity, someone knows what's going on?
\nI noticed that at first, after the publication of the notebook, it goes down for a while at the end of the list, but then rises to the top so that everyone can see it. But I never noticed (did not pay attention) that the long-published notebook went down to the bottom of the list.
Hi @aikhmelnytskyy ,
\nIt seems that \"hotness\" is a function of how recent the notebook is published and if it is being viewed/upvoted/commented by others. I checked the hotness list and found all recent notebooks to be on topfrom yours, the one notebook which was an exception to the list might be because someone viewed/upvoted/commented on it. This is my personal hypothesis and not sure of the actual algorithm in play here.
\nThanks and Regards,
\nSaurabh Bagchi
Hello! You are absolutely right! BUT my notebooks were at the very end of the \"hotness\" list, each of them has 50+ votes and people kept voting for them. And now it looks like the notebooks for which 1-3 votes were cast and the ones published earlier are higher than my best notebooks. As I understand it, this problem is not only mine. I think there is some reason why. Note that to see my notebooks you need to either go to the end of the list or change the sort type. In fact, only some people see my notebooks now (
", "rawMarkdown": "Hello! You are absolutely right! BUT my notebooks were at the very end of the \"hotness\" list, each of them has 50+ votes and people kept voting for them. And now it looks like the notebooks for which 1-3 votes were cast and the ones published earlier are higher than my best notebooks. As I understand it, this problem is not only mine. I think there is some reason why. Note that to see my notebooks you need to either go to the end of the list or change the sort type. In fact, only some people see my notebooks now (", "votes": null }, { "id": "1200582", "postDate": "02/14/2021 18:58:51", "content": "Okay, but definitely you are on the path of earning a competition medal, good luck!
", "rawMarkdown": "Okay, but definitely you are on the path of earning a competition medal, good luck!", "votes": null }, { "id": "1200603", "postDate": "02/14/2021 19:27:06", "content": "Thank you and good luck too !!!
", "rawMarkdown": "Thank you and good luck too !!!", "votes": null }, { "id": "1201059", "postDate": "02/15/2021 06:25:50", "content": "I don't know what it is lately. In my opinion the hotness sorting is broken, but others dont seem to have such a big issue with it. Hotness to me should be a function of the velocity of votes in the recent past, but it seems to be just sort by new and then beyond a few days of age just random sort.
", "rawMarkdown": "I don't know what it is lately. In my opinion the hotness sorting is broken, but others dont seem to have such a big issue with it. Hotness to me should be a function of the velocity of votes in the recent past, but it seems to be just sort by new and then beyond a few days of age just random sort.", "votes": null }, { "id": "1201369", "postDate": "02/15/2021 11:20:47", "content": "Why would it stay at the top?
\nI never understood how the hotness algorithm works, and, as a result, I usually sort by newest first to make sure I don't miss new stuff.
", "rawMarkdown": "Why would it stay at the top?\n\nI never understood how the hotness algorithm works, and, as a result, I usually sort by newest first to make sure I don't miss new stuff.", "votes": null }, { "id": "1201427", "postDate": "02/15/2021 11:52:15", "content": "Yes, it's true, but the funny thing is that my other notebook remained at the top of the list, and there were only 13 votes. At any other sorting my notebooks are displayed approximately as it should be (in the places in comparison with other notebooks). There is nothing wrong with the fact that notebooks are dropped over time in this list, and the fact that new ones appear at the top is great, but I'm still a little sad that the \"home page\" for my notebooks is actually closed. And the person who just copied my notebook and published it as his in the middle of the list :(
", "rawMarkdown": "Yes, it's true, but the funny thing is that my other notebook remained at the top of the list, and there were only 13 votes. At any other sorting my notebooks are displayed approximately as it should be (in the places in comparison with other notebooks). There is nothing wrong with the fact that notebooks are dropped over time in this list, and the fact that new ones appear at the top is great, but I'm still a little sad that the \"home page\" for my notebooks is actually closed. And the person who just copied my notebook and published it as his in the middle of the list :(", "votes": null } ], "comments": [ { "id": 1199745, "author_name": "saurabhbagchi", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/14/2021 05:09:30", "content": "Hi @aikhmelnytskyy ,
\nIt seems that \"hotness\" is a function of how recent the notebook is published and if it is being viewed/upvoted/commented by others. I checked the hotness list and found all recent notebooks to be on topfrom yours, the one notebook which was an exception to the list might be because someone viewed/upvoted/commented on it. This is my personal hypothesis and not sure of the actual algorithm in play here.
\nThanks and Regards,
\nSaurabh Bagchi
Hello! You are absolutely right! BUT my notebooks were at the very end of the \"hotness\" list, each of them has 50+ votes and people kept voting for them. And now it looks like the notebooks for which 1-3 votes were cast and the ones published earlier are higher than my best notebooks. As I understand it, this problem is not only mine. I think there is some reason why. Note that to see my notebooks you need to either go to the end of the list or change the sort type. In fact, only some people see my notebooks now (
", "votes": null, "replies": [] }, { "id": 1200582, "author_name": "saurabhbagchi", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/14/2021 18:58:51", "content": "Okay, but definitely you are on the path of earning a competition medal, good luck!
", "votes": null, "replies": [] }, { "id": 1200603, "author_name": "aikhmelnytskyy", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/14/2021 19:27:06", "content": "Thank you and good luck too !!!
", "votes": null, "replies": [] }, { "id": 1201059, "author_name": "ryches", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/15/2021 06:25:50", "content": "I don't know what it is lately. In my opinion the hotness sorting is broken, but others dont seem to have such a big issue with it. Hotness to me should be a function of the velocity of votes in the recent past, but it seems to be just sort by new and then beyond a few days of age just random sort.
", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ] }, { "id": 1201369, "author_name": "cpmpml", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/15/2021 11:20:47", "content": "Why would it stay at the top?
\nI never understood how the hotness algorithm works, and, as a result, I usually sort by newest first to make sure I don't miss new stuff.
", "votes": null, "replies": [ { "id": 1201427, "author_name": "aikhmelnytskyy", "author_url": "", "post_date": "02/15/2021 11:52:15", "content": "Yes, it's true, but the funny thing is that my other notebook remained at the top of the list, and there were only 13 votes. At any other sorting my notebooks are displayed approximately as it should be (in the places in comparison with other notebooks). There is nothing wrong with the fact that notebooks are dropped over time in this list, and the fact that new ones appear at the top is great, but I'm still a little sad that the \"home page\" for my notebooks is actually closed. And the person who just copied my notebook and published it as his in the middle of the list :(
", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ] } ], "raw_markdown_by_id": { "1198251": "Hi to all!\nToday I noticed that my public notebooks have shifted from the top of the \"Hotness\" list to the end. Out of curiosity, someone knows what's going on?\nI noticed that at first, after the publication of the notebook, it goes down for a while at the end of the list, but then rises to the top so that everyone can see it. But I never noticed (did not pay attention) that the long-published notebook went down to the bottom of the list.", "1199745": "Hi @aikhmelnytskyy ,\n\nIt seems that \"hotness\" is a function of how recent the notebook is published and if it is being viewed/upvoted/commented by others. I checked the hotness list and found all recent notebooks to be on topfrom yours, the one notebook which was an exception to the list might be because someone viewed/upvoted/commented on it. This is my personal hypothesis and not sure of the actual algorithm in play here.\n\nThanks and Regards,\nSaurabh Bagchi", "1200299": "Hello! You are absolutely right! BUT my notebooks were at the very end of the \"hotness\" list, each of them has 50+ votes and people kept voting for them. And now it looks like the notebooks for which 1-3 votes were cast and the ones published earlier are higher than my best notebooks. As I understand it, this problem is not only mine. I think there is some reason why. Note that to see my notebooks you need to either go to the end of the list or change the sort type. In fact, only some people see my notebooks now (", "1200582": "Okay, but definitely you are on the path of earning a competition medal, good luck!", "1200603": "Thank you and good luck too !!!", "1201059": "I don't know what it is lately. In my opinion the hotness sorting is broken, but others dont seem to have such a big issue with it. Hotness to me should be a function of the velocity of votes in the recent past, but it seems to be just sort by new and then beyond a few days of age just random sort.", "1201369": "Why would it stay at the top?\n\nI never understood how the hotness algorithm works, and, as a result, I usually sort by newest first to make sure I don't miss new stuff.", "1201427": "Yes, it's true, but the funny thing is that my other notebook remained at the top of the list, and there were only 13 votes. At any other sorting my notebooks are displayed approximately as it should be (in the places in comparison with other notebooks). There is nothing wrong with the fact that notebooks are dropped over time in this list, and the fact that new ones appear at the top is great, but I'm still a little sad that the \"home page\" for my notebooks is actually closed. And the person who just copied my notebook and published it as his in the middle of the list :(" }, "source": "meta" }